Missing Since: 07/06/04
Missing from: Indianapolis, Indiana
Date Of Birth: 06/13/82
Age at disappearance: 23
Height: 5’0″- 5’1″
Weight: 100 – 105 lbs.
Hair Color: Brown, with Blonde highlights
Eye Color: Green/Hazel
Distinguishing Characteristics: Right arm has dime-sized
birthmark, outside of elbow. Tip of left thumbnail visibly
deformed. Wears eyeglasses or clear contacts.
Clothing: Pink tie-dye shirt with a white collar.
Details of Disappearance
Dattilo is a straight A student at Eastern Kentucky University where she has a track scholarship. This summer she was living with her brother in Indianapolis and taking summer classes at Indiana University Purdue University at Indianapolis.
On July 6, 2004 Molly attended two classes; she ran some errands; she talked to friends. Then around 7:30 that night she told her brother she was walking to a nearby Wendy’s Restaurant to fill out an application. She hasn’t been seen since.
In the apartment she shared with her brother Molly left behind her cell phone, her identification and her ATM card. Her clothes were also left behind and there is no evidence that she packed a bag.
Molly was actively working toward an August audition for American Idol. Since her disappearance, she hasn’t contacted her voice coach and she left practice equipment inside her car.
Marion County Sheriff’s Department